Current location:style >>
Curb on Chinese talent sparks strong backlash
style4People have gathered around
IntroductionA Florida law barring public universities from hiring researchers from China is facing mounting crit ...
A Florida law barring public universities from hiring researchers from China is facing mounting criticism from academics and advocates for its potential to cripple scientific progress in the United States.
The National Postdoctoral Association, or NPA, a leading advocate for postdoctoral researchers, or postdocs, in the U.S., has recently joined the fight against the law, advocating for the freedom to hire top talent regardless of national origin.
"We oppose any bill that bans international students or postdocs from studying or working at public universities. This approach benefits no one and harms both the individual seeking to come to the U.S. and our national research efforts," Thomas Kimbis, executive director and CEO of NPA, told China Daily.
The law, SB 846, took effect on July 1, 2023. It prohibits Florida's 12 public colleges and universities from taking money from or partnering with entities in China and six other "countries of concern", including Russia, Cuba, Iran, Syria and Venezuela.
The list of banned interactions includes offering anyone living in one of those countries a contract to do research.
"The bill, intentionally or not, can cause a significant slowdown in the process of becoming a paid graduate student or postdoc at a variety of state institutions," said Kimbis.
"Postdocs in particular already face a difficult immigration journey and don't need to have any additional delays that are accompanied by a lack of clarity of process," he added.
Kimbis emphasized the crucial role of scientists born outside the U.S. in driving global innovation as well as U.S. economic, societal and health advancement.
"Nearly 60 percent of our postdoc population comes from outside the U.S. — a figure that is steadily increasing," he said, adding that this group plays a significant role in advancing research and development across various disciplines.
Lost opportunity
Kimbis also expressed concerns about a potential brain drain by turning away the brightest minds — "a lost opportunity for innovation that could threaten the very national security that SB 846 purports to protect", he said.
Faculty members at the University of Florida, or UF, which boasts the state's largest research portfolio, have been most vocal in opposition. More than 350 have signed a petition since December urging the university to disregard nationality when recruiting top graduate students.
They warn that "failure to act swiftly" will result in losing exceptional talent to other universities and cause "irreversible damage".
The law applies to all academic interactions with China and the other six countries. Exceptions are allowed only when the Board of Governors, which oversees higher education in the state, grants a waiver on a case-by-case basis. But it isn't clear how it would be implemented.
The law's ambiguity regarding implementation has left faculty members in a state of confusion. Professors across various disciplines at the UF have voiced their concerns, as shown in their comments on the petition's endorsement form.
Fred Gmitter, a professor of horticultural sciences, slammed the law as "counterproductive" and an attack on academic freedom.
"Excessive political interference in the affairs of a public university is counterproductive and contrary to the fundamental concepts of academic freedom," he said, "This bill is dragging UF down, not lifting us up."
Emma MacKie, assistant professor of geological sciences, highlighted the detrimental impact on accessing international talent.
"China and Iran are powerhouse incubators for geological talent, with a disproportionate number of students studying geology and geophysics, especially in industry or applied geoscience topics," she said. "We cannot strive to be a top 10 department if we can't access or collaborate with a significant fraction of the world's top geoscientists," she continued.
Tags:
Reprint:Friends are welcome to share on the Internet, but please indicate the source of the article when reprinting it.“Global Gazetteer news portal”。http://southafrica.intifocus.com/content-37b499914.html
Related articles
Wisconsin judge dismisses lawsuit challenging state's new wolf management plan
styleMADISON, Wis. (AP) — A lawsuit filed by animal welfare advocates seeking to invalidate Wisconsin’s n ...
【style】
Read moreCoalition talks: No more face to face meetings this weekend
styleChristopher Luxon and Nicola Willis arrive at the Cordis hotel on Sunday. Photo: RNZ / Giles Dexter ...
【style】
Read moreAuckland's rail operators promise city's trains will run more smoothly
styleA new control centre means staff from One Rail, KiwiRail and Auckland Transport will work one office ...
【style】
Read more
Popular articles
- Anaheim Ducks goaltending coach Sudarshan Maharaj declared cancer
- Large blaze at Auckland scrap metal site contained
- Ministry for the Environment asks for voluntary redundancies
- Man arrested after alleged stabbing in Papamoa, Bay of Plenty
- Trump faces jail threat over gag order as prosecutors zero in on transactions at heart of the case
- Winston Peters says Gaza 'a wasteland', criticises UN Security Council in speech
Latest articles
Travis Kelce parties at star
Public sector workers 'angry, annoyed' at government job cuts
New Climate Change Minister Simon Watts not expecting criticism at COP28 over fossil fuels U
Fallen 'Crypto King' Sam Bankman
Guardians place AL
David Cameron's Falklands visit prompts playful dig from Buenos Aires
LINKS
- Natalie Spooner leads Toronto to 5
- Shohei Ohtani homers twice as Dodgers sweep Braves with 5
- Lando Norris earns 1st career F1 victory by ending Verstappen's dominance at Miami
- Charlie Puth responds to Taylor Swift dropping his name in her record
- Review planned for vaccine payouts as claims soar following the pandemic
- Maryland bus crash: 1 person killed and 23 injured
- Heartbroken Zoe Ball pays tribute to late partner Billy Yates seven years since his passing
- UK's ruling Conservative Party suffers heavy losses in local elections
- Urgent search for P&O cruise ship passenger feared to have fallen overboard near Sydney Harbour
- London mayor race: Labour's Sadiq Khan to secure record third term